If sending pies to 5 or more recipients, please visit our Corporate & Large Gift Order page.

The best of both worlds!!

Texas Trash Pie

Coconut, chocolate chips, graham crackers, pretzels and caramel…this is a toooo die for pie!!!

Sweet 'N Salty Pie

One of our FAVS! Dense, brownie like with caramel and sea salt

Red Velvet Oreo

oh my PIE! this one is the real deal!! a gooey red velvet with chucks of oreo. warmed up or not this one is TO PIE FOR!

Bud's Chocolate Chip Pie

The Claim to Fame! It’s like a big Chocolate Chip Cookie with tiny bits of pecans—only better!

Ann's Pecan Pie

Pa-can” not “Pee-can!” This one is perfect, not too sweet and doesn’t have a strong dark Karo flavor!

Butterscotch Chip Pie

Just like Bud’s Chocolate Chip but with butterscotch chips. Rich, gooey & caramel!! Rick Perry’s fave

Cafe’s Original Buttermilk Pie

Dense custard pie with a hint of nutmeg. Just like grandma makes!

Buttermilk Delight Pie

One day we accidentally added pecans, coconut, & chocolate chips into the buttermilk base and OMG yummm!

Key Lime Chess Pie

Just the perfect mix of sweet & tart! Top it with powdered sugar!

Sugar Free Pecan

pecan pie made with sugar free honey

Peanut Butter White Trash

Creamy peanut butter, coconut, pretzels, graham crackers, caramel bits, white chocolate chips

HAWT Chocolate

chocolate chess pie with a kick of habanero

Not My Moms Apple Pie

Six whole Granny Smith apples, in a sinful filling of brown sugar and whipping cream AND topped with a pecan and brown sugar streusel…Holy Cow!

Shannon's Blueberry Lemon Pie

Our fabulous blueberry filling layered with cream cheese & lemon zest topped with a granola topping.

D'ette's Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

OMG! With a granola topping to die for!

Bob's Cherry Pie

Not too sour and not too sweet with a lattice top.

Dr. Karen’s Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin, cream & all the right spices

Sam’s Lemon Chess Pie

lemon chess pie with coconut

Margherita Chicken Pizza Pie

Fresh mozzarella, basil, tomatoes, basil, tomatoes & chicken in our herb crust!

Hee Haw Pie

Egg, sausage, bacon, jalapeños, onions & cheddar cheese

Chicken Pot Pie

Veggies & grilled chicken in a creamy Alfredo sauce in our herb crust

Veggie Pie

Feta, sun-dried tomatoes, onion, cheddar, spinach & portobello mushrooms

DUE TO FOOD SAFETY PLEASE SELECT 2ND DAY AIR OR NEXT DAY AIR AT CHECKOUT